The best places in Dayton to order scrumptious, locally baked Thanksgiving pies


What is Thanksgiving without pie? The good news is you can spend zero time in the kitchen and still serve an assortment of delicious discs of love at your table. 


>> How to take a whack out of this addictive new Dayton pie

>> How to nominate your favorites for Best of Dayton 2018

Besides the major grocery stores, here are some of our favorite go-to places for pies: 

*Note: Some shops and bakeries have deadlines to order pie before Thanksgiving.

A new and independently owned bakery founded by a local father-daughter duo has set an opening date of July 27 near the University of Dayton campus. “Partial to Pie” is gearing up to open at 200 Shroyer Road, at the intersection of Shroyer and Wilmington Pike. STAFF PHOTO / MARK FISHER
Photo: Mark Fisher

🥧Mimi’s Cafe

4402 Walnut St., Beavercreek | Website

Mimi’s will offer whole pumpkin ($16.99) and pecan pies ($17.99) to take home on the day of Thanksgiving. 

🥧Partial to Pie Bakery

200 Shroyer Road | WebsiteFacebook

You’ll have to call soon to order a Partial to Pie goodie for the holiday. The Thanksgiving orders deadline is November 10. You can expect classic pies from these guys— cherry, blueberry, blackberry and mixed berry. Then for the fruit fans— peach, apple, apple crumb and peach mango. The bakery’s quiche also has earned quite the reputation. Call 937-813-8851 to place an order. 

>>PREVIOUS COVERAGE: New Dayton pie shop plans soft launch later this week

The newest pie aficionados in Dayton are ready to show what they’re made of, literally, this Thanksgiving season.  

The strawberry pie at Mehaffies Pies in Dayton is the most popular throughout summer. (Staff photo by Connie Post)

🥧Mehaffie's Pies

3013 Linden Ave. | Website

Mehaffie’s offers 30 different types of pies. For orders, call 937-253-1163, preferably two days in advance. Pick up your pies Monday through Wednesday before Thanksgiving from 8 a.m. – 6 p.m. The bakery will also have plenty of pies (especially pumpkin, apple, pecan and chocolate) available for walk-in purchases as well. Most pies are $8.50 or $8.75. Mehaffie’s also offers several types of New York-style cheesecake, ranging from $9.25-$13.25. 

Ghostlight Coffee shop has added the Lumberjack Pie to its Thanksgiving dessert menu. Photo: Amelia Robinson

🥧Ghostlight Coffee

1201 Wayne Ave. | WebsiteFacebook

Ghostlight is taking pre-orders for its popular Ghostlight Thanksgiving dessert menu. The star of this year’s menu is the Lumberjack pie. The 10-inch pie can be pre-ordered for the holiday or requested by special order now, said Shane Anderson, owner of the coffee shop located at 1201 Wayne Ave. in Dayton’s South Park neighborhood. The coffee shop/bakery also offers Mama Smith’s fantastic apple pie ($16), made with apples from Pfeifer Orchards in Yellow Springs; pumpkin & maple ($16); Kentucky bourbon pecan ($17); bourbon sweet potato ($19 and gluten free), and cranberry apple with pecan crumble ($19 and gluten free). 

Plus, there are gluten-free dinner rolls (6 pack for $7.50), pumpkin snickerdoodles (a dozen vegan and nut free, $9); and Fall Tonic Autumn Blend coffee (12 ounces, $14.25). 

The order deadline is Saturday, Nov.17 by noon. Pick-up Dates: Tuesday, Nov. 20, 12-5 p.m. or Wednesday, Nov. 21, 12-5 p.m.

If you have questions, call 937-985-2633 or email Order online at

Ashley's Pastry Shop in Oakwood offers a wide variety of traditional and specialty pastries, pies and other treats.

🥧Ashley’s Pastry Shop

21 Park Ave. in Oakwood | WebsiteFacebook

Ashley’s is taking orders for all sorts of pies, including apple, cherry, pumpkin, pecan, lemon meringue, chocolate cream and blueberry. Prices are $10.95-$15.95. The bakery also makes cakes, cookies, cupcakes, cake pops, traditional dinner rolls and its famous butterscotch rolls.

Ashley's Pastry Shop sells hundreds of dozens of Butterscotch Rolls every Thanksgiving and ships them all over the country to people who want an authentic taste of Dayton on their holiday plate.

>>Meet the woman behind one of Dayton’s most beloved bakeries

Owner Theresa Hammons told us she sold 780 dozen butterscotch rolls on the day before Thanksgiving last year and shipped another 300 dozen all over the country. “Thanksgiving is about tradition,” Hammons said. “Sharing a meal together with the ones you love.”

A 48- to 72-hour notice is preferred but the shop will always try to fill your order. You can pick up your order as late as the day before Thanksgiving, when the shop is open 7 a.m. - 6 p.m. Info: (937) 293-1719 or

>> These cookies are so good Allison Janney gets them ordered on set

Jennifer Evans works in her family bakery in Old North Dayton. The business has hired individuals in recovery who live at Good Shepherd Ministries sober living homes. KATIE WEDELL/STAFF
Photo: Katie Wedell

🥧Evans Bakery

700 Troy St. | Facebook 

Evans is taking orders for 15 different types of pies, ranging from pumpkin and sweet potato to peanut butter and pecan. They also offer rolls (challah to potato to butter flake), cookies and more. Call by Monday, Nov. 19. The last day to pick up your goodies is Wednesday, Nov. 21, between 6 a.m. and 3 p.m. Owner Jennifer Evans also told us she'd have some pies available for walk-ins that week. To order: (937) 228-4151. 

Apple pie from Dorothy Lane Market.

🥧Dorothy Lane Market 


Locations: 2179 Far Hills Ave., Oakwood; 6177 Far Hills Avenue, Centerville; 740 N. Main St., Springboro

DLM is offering traditional pumpkin, pecan, apple, apple crumb, caramel apple, cherry, peach, strawberry rhubarb and mincemeat, as well as an assortment of cream pies. DLM is a great option for last-minute pie needs, as they only ask for a 24-hour notice and you can even order on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving. All DLM locations, EXCEPT for Oakwood, close at 11 p.m. The Oakwood branch closes at midnight on Wednesday, Nov. 21 before Thanksgiving. You must place your order by calling 937-434-1294 and asking for the bakery.

>> 70 reasons we love Dorothy Lane Market

Cara Andres, retail bakery associate at Dorothy Lane Market, arranges over a dozen varieties of bread at the Washington Twp. store. LISA POWELL / STAFF
Photo: Lisa Powell
Bob Bianco’s Apple Pie from Pearson House Restaurant in West Milton.

🥧Pearson House Restaurant

28 N. Miami St. in West Milton | WebsiteFacebook

Pearson House is known for its decadent pies and is taking orders for more than 30 types, including pumpkin, pecan, turtle, chocolate peanut butter silk, cranberry-walnut and strawberry rhubarb. Pies cost $11-$19. Info: (937) 698-6665 or

Bob Bianco shows off a piece of his homemade strawberry rhubarb pie. He and his wife, Beth, have operated the Pearson House Restaurant in West Milton for the past 30 years.

🥧Corner Kitchen

613 E. 5th St., Dayton | WebsiteFacebook

Corner Kitchen offers apple, pumpkin and pecan pies. You can even grab a pint or quart of Corner’s house-made whipped cream. Other Thanksgiving goodies include mashed potatoes, sweet potato souffle, Brussel hash, green beans, stuffing, cranberry sauce, gravy and cranberry orange bread. The Kitchen asks that you please submit order requests by 5 p.m. on Monday, November 19. Pick-up on Wednesday between 12 p.m. and 8 p.m. To place an order, contact Corner Kitchen at 937-719-0999 or

🥧Frisch’s will be offering apple, cherry, pecan, chocolate cream, peanut butter, coconut cream, pumpkin and mint, ranging between $9.99 and $16.75. Call a couple days in advance to the store location where you wish to pick up your pie by Thanksgiving Day. Store locations: 

🥧Perkins Restaurant & Bakery offers more than 8 different whole pies to-go, including pumpkin, cherry, caramel apple and coconut cream. They all cost about $11.99-$13.99. Call a few days ahead to guarantee that the pie you want will be ready for pickup. however you can place an order the day of and Perkins will try and fill your order for you— even the day of Thanksgiving. Perkins will be open for Thanksgiving, but with reduced hours at most Dayton-area locations— 6 a.m. to 4 p.m. To find your nearest location, go to 

🥧Bob Evans offers pies to go including pumpkin, pumpkin supreme (think pumpkin pie layered with cheesecake), double crust apple pie, chocolate peanut butter pie topped with Reese’s peanut butter cups and coconut cream pie. ($10.99-12.49). You can place your order online or call your local location