Caption

LOCAL RESTAURANT CLOSING: Try this deliciously saucy burger before it’s too late 

After a decade of slinging burgers and booking bands, a well-known Dayton area restaurant is closing up shop for good.

>> Best of Dayton 2017 Winners: Food & Dining

One Eyed Jacks, located at 2638 Colonel Glenn Highway in Fairborn near Wright State University, will permanently close on Saturday, Feb. 24, co-owner Bill Mangan said. 

>> 12 of the best restaurants in Dayton

The decision was made not to renew the lease after a satisfactory agreement could not be reach with the building’s owner, he said. 

Recommended for you

Recommended for you

Recommended for you

Most read

  1. 1 Victor's Taco Shop one of the best Mexican restaurants in Dayton
  2. 2 Ohio Chipotle stool samples test positive for foodborne disease
  3. 3 The best bowls from CoreLife Eatery | Dayton, OH

>> Dayton.com Best of 2017 Winners: Bars & Nightlife

One Eyed Jack's will close permanently February 24. (Photo: Amelia Robinson) (Photo: Amelia Robinson)

“We did really well there for a long time, but it’s been waning there for the last two years,” Mangan said. 

>> This Wahlburgers restaurant is now OPEN -- and it’s just a short drive from Dayton

The last night will include local entertainment from a yet-to-be announced group of local musicians. 

One Eyed Jack’s last show will be the “Jacks I Love Hip Hop Farewell Show” from 9 p.m. to 2:30 a.m. Friday, Feb. 23. 

Vast Aire of Cannibal Ox will headline the free show. V.I.P admission is $15. Ages 18 and up only. For more information, visit brownpapertickets.com

>> Allison Janney: “Dayton spawns great people”

Mangan said he was happy to provide a venue where local musicians of various genres could meet and perform. 

“Until you get a chance to perform in a live venue, you don’t know what you are capable of doing,” he said. “We were a launch pad for a lot of bands.”

Think if you've had one burger you've had them all? Take a look at at these and up your burger eating game. (Video by Tabatha Wharton)

>> PREVIOUS COVERAGE: Kettering restaurant closes over parking dispute (Sept. 3, 2014)

Mangan, also the owner of Cherry House Cafe, a deli at  1241 Meadow Bridge Dr. in Beavercreek, said he was thankful for the customers that supported One Eyed Jacks.

“We look forward to serving them at Cherry House if they come up this way,” he said. 

>> 2 local restaurants make ‘Top Brunch in Ohio’ list

WHAT ABOUT THE FOOD?

One Eyed Jacks became known for its chicken wings and the burgers patties made daily by “Big” Ben Mangan, Bill Mangan’s son.

Burger Fast Facts

>> Here’s how to eat around the world at this local strip mall

At the urging of Dayton sandwich lover Nick Warrington, a Wright State alum and the university’s assistant director of  alumni, I gave One Eyed Jacks Bloomin’ Onion Burger a try. 

Nick raved about the restaurant’s tatonka sauce in a Facebook message:

“As a sandwich guru, I hope you have tried their sandwiches with their ‘famous tatonka sauce,’” he said in a message.

One Eyed Jack's will close permanently February 24. The restaurant's Bloomn' Onion burger and fries are pictured. (Photo: Amelia Robinson) (Photo: Amelia Robinson)

As Bill Mangan later explained, the sauce -- which is also served on the restaurant’s Veggie Zaffer black bean burger -- was inspired partly by Buffalo-style hot sauce. 

>> Your ultimate guide to the best burgers in Dayton

He kept the spicy secrets to the creation to himself. 

My burger came out fresh and topped with layers of onion rings, tomato, lettuce, provolone cheese, onion and One Eyed Jacks creamy tatonka sauce with its slight kick.

The thick cheeseburger was well-seasoned with juices that melted into the sesame seed bun it came between. 

My lunch came with a mound of crispy, munchable seasoned fries for $9.95.

Each of One Eyed Jacks nine special burgers are eight ounces and cost $8.95 with house made Saratoga potato chips and a pickle spear. 

 >> FISH FRY GUIDE: The best places to get deep-fried, crispy, delicious fish in Dayton

LAST CHANCE

Until it closes on Feb. 24, 2018, the restaurant is open 11 a.m. to 2:30 a.m. Monday to Friday and noon to 2:30 a.m. Saturday and Sunday. 

One Eyed Jack's will close permanently February 24. The restaurant's Bloomn' Onion burger and fries are pictured. (Photo: Amelia Robinson) (Photo: Amelia Robinson)

 

One Eyed Jack's will close permanently February 24. (Photo: Amelia Robinson) (Photo: Amelia Robinson)

More from Dayton