The secrets to a perfect pie from Dayton’s newest pie bakery

Partial to Pie Bakery officially opened for business on July 31 this year. The focus of the business is all in the name.

“We are a bakery with a strong focus on pies and quiche,” said owner Marie Clark, who jokes she’s also the cashier, baker and janitor. “We make our baked goods fresh every day with quality ingredients, while also focusing on the use of local fresh ingredients when available.”

This business started from years of Clark baking with her dad Mike Clark for festivals, while they both worked full-time jobs.

>> PREVIOUS COVERAGE: A sneak peek inside new Partial to Pie Bakery

During that time Clark went through the business program at Sinclair Community College and Partial to Pie Bakery ended up becoming her business plan.

She works with her dad to create a set menu daily, with weekly and seasonal items like pumpkin, pecan and sweet potato in the fall.

>> BEST OF DAYTON: Partial to Pie is a finalist for Best Place for Dessert

Currently they sell their products exclusively out of the bakery at 200 Shroyer Road. There is dine-in seating where you can enjoy a snack, meal or dessert in the form of quiche, savory meat pies or traditional dessert pies. Clark says she hopes to work with some other businesses in the future to do some wholesaling business.

>> BEST OF DAYTON: Cast your vote for Dayton’s Best Bakery

Winter is a season for pies of all types and the holidays are especially pie-oriented. Clark estimates they make about 125 pies in a typical week, with customers purchasing what’s in stock or ordering whole pies or quiche over the phone or via email with two days notice.

The voting in's Best of 2018 contest has started! Click the button below to start telling us your favorites.

Despite a busy schedule, Clark took time out to answer some questions about her new business.

Q: How did you get started cooking?

A: My family has always cooked and baked a lot, so I grew up around it and was helping out at a very young age.

Q: What do you have to do to make a great pie?

A: Take your time and don't try to rush the process. Balance the flavors and always use cold butter and cold water when making pie crusts.

>> What you need to know about Dayton’s newest pie shop

Q: What makes your pies special?

A: We focus on using quality ingredients, and all of our pies are made fresh daily. Also our pies tend to be less sweet than many on the market, which allows the flavor of the fruit to really shine. We have not had much time yet to take on a bunch of special requests, but we currently make our fruit pies either vegan or gluten-free upon request. A couple times we have even made a gluten-free and vegan pie for our customers.

Q: What’s the craziest pie you’ve ever made?

A: I don't know about the craziest, but a few interesting ones I have done are paw-paw, persimmon, eggnog and mud cake pie.

Q: Are your ingredients special?

A: We use as many local products as we can. Our butter, milk, eggs, cream and meat products are all sourced locally. We also use local apples in season. All of our pumpkin pies and sweet potato pies are made with local fresh pumpkins and sweet potatoes. We will use other local fruits and veggies when they are available in season. Also we focus on using the least amount of processed raw goods that we can.

Q: When did you make your first pie?

A: I don't remember making my first pie but I remember early on making pies with my dad and being frustrated because I could not roll out a crust for the life of me. We starting really making pies for the Aullwood Apple Fest and the interest in pies just grew from there.

Q: Will you have any special pies for sale in December?

A: We are doing a final test baking on Mince Meat pie and Persimmon Pie. They should be available by sometime next week. We are also offering a couple non-pie options for the holidays. We have fruit cakes available soaked in different alcohols. Also we have a couple of Eastern European baked goods Potica and Kifle, which the original recipes came from the South Slavic Club of Dayton. Our pies are packed full of flavor with either tons of fruit in them or rich flavors in the cream pies. Customers can buy our pies by the slice, mini, whole or "pie pocket." Whole pies range from $15-$18 depending on the variety.

Q: What makes this a good option for people in your opinion?

A: It's a great bakery spot that you can actually sit and stay awhile, not just for carryout. Also we offer quiche, which I briefly mentioned before, but that is a big sell item here, pretty much as much as we sell our regular pies.

Q: What do you think makes pies great?


They are very versatile. You can put almost anything in a pie and get away with it. Also I feel a lot of people have a connection with pie, whether it was their mom, grandma or uncle who used to make a particular pie every year. We have heard so many stories from our customers about a fond memory they have with pie. It’s a great time of the year for gifting and sharing with friends and family and what better way to do that than with pie?


What: Partial to Pie Bakery

Where: 200 Shroyer Road, Dayton.

More information: 937-813-8851 or Email with questions.

Hours: 7 a.m.-5:30 p.m.Tuesday-Friday and 7 a.m.-2 p.m. Saturdays. Closed Sundays and Mondays.

About the Author